Your quote against a public benchmark
Rooftop Payback Estimator
Bring a real quote if you have one. The tool prices it against the U.S. Department of Energy's Q1 2025 residential benchmark of $2.95 per watt DC, estimates first-year production from the planning factor for your area, and computes simple payback and a 25-year net with slow panel degradation and flat electricity prices. Change any input; the defaults are a stated example, not a market survey.
- DOE Q1 2025 benchmark, checked October 30, 2026
- No federal credit assumed after 2025
- Only incentives you confirm are counted
Show the numbers behind this chart
| Item | Phoenix example |
|---|---|
| Up-front cost at the benchmark | $23,600 |
| First-year savings | $2,112 |
| Simple payback | 11.2 years |
Example quote, replace with yours
The starting values are a labelled example: a $23,600 quote for an 8 kW system, a $180 monthly bill, and the planning rate and production for the selected metro example. $23,600 divided by 8,000 watts is $2.95 per watt, the U.S. Department of Energy's Q1 2025 residential benchmark (2024 dollars) used on this site. Replace every value with your quote and your bill.
Saved on this device only. Your entries are kept in this browser so you can return to them, and they are not sent anywhere by this tool.
At $2.95 per watt, this quote is in the neighbourhood of the DOE Q1 2025 residential benchmark of $2.95 per watt (checked October 30, 2026). Equipment, roof work, and warranty decide whether it is fair.
- Quoted price per watt
- $2.95
- Estimated first-year production
- 13,200 kWh
- Share of current usage offset
- About 98%
- Estimated first-year bill savings
- $2,112
- Net cost after incentives you entered
- $23,600
- Simple payback
- 11.2 years
- 25-year net (0.5% yearly degradation, flat rates)
- $26,150 ahead
Work the red-flags checklist on this quote →
Assumptions, printed
Planning estimate only. Production depends on roof angle, shade, and weather; savings depend on your tariff and net metering rules, which change. The federal residential solar tax credit ended for systems placed in service after 2025, so this tool assumes no federal credit unless you enter a confirmed incentive yourself. Model your roof in NREL PVWatts and check incentives in DSIRE before deciding.
My quote vs benchmark, and the flags to raise
- Quote entered:
- $23,600 for 8 kW in Phoenix, Arizona
- Price per watt:
- $2.95 against the $2.95 DOE Q1 2025 benchmark
- Estimated first-year production:
- 13,200 kWh
- Estimated first-year bill savings:
- $2,112
- Net cost after incentives you entered:
- $23,600
- Simple payback:
- 11.2 years
Flags to raise with the installer
- Price per watt is $2.95, at or below the $2.95 benchmark. Price alone is not a flag on these inputs.
- No incentive is entered. Do not let a quote subtract an incentive you have not confirmed in DSIRE or your tariff.
- Check the export value inside any payback claim against your utility tariff, and ask for the production tool, tilt, direction, and shade inputs behind the estimate.
Planning estimate only, from the inputs above. Saved on this device only.
How to use the verdict
- Below the benchmark: price is unlikely to be your problem. Spend your diligence on equipment, warranties, and the installer.
- Near the benchmark: normal territory. Roof work, electrical upgrades, and equipment tier should explain the exact position.
- Well above the benchmark: the quote owes you a line-by-line explanation and at least two competitors. Pull two more quotes from the national solar installation companies in the directory.
Assumptions, printed rather than buried
Payback here is simple payback: net cost after only the confirmed incentives you enter, divided by first-year bill savings, followed by a 25-year net using 0.5% annual panel degradation and flat electricity prices. Savings assume production first offsets usage at the price you enter, capped at your stated annual bill. Production uses the planning factor for the metro you select, which is a starting estimate. Your roof needs its own PVWatts model with its tilt, direction, and shade before any figure deserves your signature. The full method, sources, and review process are on the methodology page.
Limits
- Production factors are planning examples for each metro, not a substitute for a PVWatts model of your roof with its tilt, direction, and shade.
- Savings assume the production offsets your usage at the price you enter. Export rules can lower the value of surplus energy; read net metering explained before trusting a savings figure.
- No federal residential credit is assumed. It ended for systems placed in service after 2025. Incentives you enter must be ones you have confirmed, ideally in DSIRE and with your utility.
Common questions
What does the $2.95 per watt benchmark actually mean?
It is the modeled market price for an 8 kW residential system in the U.S. Department of Energy's Q1 2025 solar cost benchmarks, stated in 2024 dollars with tax credits and owner subsidies excluded (checked October 30, 2026), and used here as a comparison line for quotes. It is not a quote, a price cap, or a claim about your installer. Local labor, roof condition, equipment, and electrical work move real prices in both directions. Our quote red flags guide shows how to make a higher quote explain itself.
Why is no federal tax credit in the math?
The federal residential solar tax credit ended for systems placed in service after 2025, so this site assumes none. If a quote subtracts a federal credit anyway, ask the installer to document it in an official source. State, local, and utility incentives still exist in places; confirm them in DSIRE and your utility tariff, then enter only the confirmed amount. Your state page points to what to verify.
How accurate is the production estimate?
It is a planning estimate built from a metro production factor, stated in kilowatt-hours per kW per year. Your roof angle, direction, shade, and weather will move the real figure. Ask every installer to name the tool behind their estimate and reproduce it in a public model such as NREL PVWatts. The metro pages show how the same system behaves across different sun and prices.
Why does the estimator cap savings at my bill?
Because exported surplus is often worth less than energy you consume, and a bill cannot fall below its fixed charges through production alone in most tariffs. Sizing past your usage buys cheap exports unless your export rule pays retail. Our sizing guide and net metering guide show how to size against the rule you actually live under.
Sources and verification
Cost basis: U.S. Department of Energy, Solar Photovoltaic System Cost Benchmarks, Q1 2025, Table 2 (residential 8 kW system, modeled market price $2.95 per watt DC in 2024 dollars; checked October 30, 2026). Production method: NREL PVWatts planning approach. Price context: U.S. Energy Information Administration residential price data. Incentives: DSIRE. Full detail on the methodology page. This tool provides educational planning estimates, not a quote.