Net metering and net billing: what your exported power is worth
Net metering decides what your exported solar power is worth: under full net metering an exported kilowatt-hour cancels an imported one at the retail price, while under net billing it earns a separate, lower export rate. At a labelled 30-cent retail rate and 4-cent export rate, 450 exported kWh are worth $135 under the first rule and $18 under the second. A typical grid-tied rooftop system exports power at noon and imports it at dinner, so the rule that prices those exports is worth more than another panel. It is also changing: generous one-for-one retail credit has been replaced in some states by lower export rates or partial credits, which quietly rewrites every payback estimate made under the old rules. This guide shows the same month of electricity billed three ways, reads two real rules from their source text, and works the arithmetic you need to read your own tariff. It explains rules; it is not legal or financial advice, and your utility's current tariff is the document that controls.
The three structures you will actually meet
Full retail net metering credits each exported kilowatt-hour at the retail price, effectively running the meter backward. Net billing charges retail for imports and pays a lower export rate, so self-consumption becomes the valuable behavior. Buyback plans are contracts with a retail electricity supplier that name a feed-in price, which can differ from both. The structures reward different system sizes and different habits.
A fourth shape sits between the first two and is easy to miss: partial-credit net metering, where an exported kilowatt-hour still offsets an imported one, but only against some parts of the bill. Illinois, read below from the statute, credits the supply charges and leaves the delivery charges, taxes and fees to be paid on everything the home draws from the grid. The name on the tariff may still say net metering, so read the definition of the credit, not the title.
| Structure | Export worth | Design response |
|---|---|---|
| Retail net metering | About the retail rate | Size near annual usage can make sense |
| Net billing | Below retail, sometimes far below | Size toward daytime usage; storage gains value |
| Buyback plan | The contract feed-in price | Read the plan like a tariff; it is half the product |
| Partial-credit net metering | Some charge components, such as supply | Size near usage still works, but each kWh is worth less |
The same month billed three ways
Take one household and one month: it imports 700 kWh from the grid and exports 450 kWh from its roof. Hold the panels, the weather and the habits fixed, and change only the export rule. The rates are labelled illustrations, not any utility's current prices: a 30-cent all-in retail rate, a 4-cent net billing export rate, and, for the partial-credit case, a supply portion of 12 cents within the 30-cent rate. Fixed monthly charges are left out of all three so the export rule is the only thing that moves.
Show the three bills as a table
| Export rule | How the month is priced | Energy charge |
|---|---|---|
| Full net metering | (700 - 450) kWh x $0.30 | $75 |
| Partial (supply) credit | 700 kWh x $0.30 - 450 kWh x $0.12 | $156 |
| Net billing | 700 kWh x $0.30 - 450 kWh x $0.04 | $192 |
The gap between the cheapest and dearest bill is $117 for one month, from identical sunshine. Put another way, the 450 exported kilowatt-hours were worth $135 under full net metering, $54 under the partial credit and $18 under net billing. That is the number to carry into a payback estimate: not what the panels produce, but what each exported kilowatt-hour earns under your rule, times how many you export. A household that uses most of its solar as it is produced exports less and is hurt less by a low export rate, which is why the self-consumed share matters more under the second and third rules than under the first.
Where net metering comes from: a federal standard states could decline
It is easy to assume net metering is a federal requirement. It is not, quite. The Energy Policy Act of 2005, in section 1251, added a net metering standard to the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act, now at 16 U.S.C. 2621(d)(11). The standard says each electric utility shall make net metering service available on request, and defines that service as one under which electric energy generated by the consumer from an eligible on-site generating facility and delivered to the local distribution facilities may be used to offset electric energy provided by the utility to the consumer during the applicable billing period.
The catch is in subsection (a) of the same section. Each state regulatory authority, and each nonregulated utility, was required to consider the standard and make a determination about whether it is appropriate to implement it, and the statute says nothing in that subsection prohibits a state from determining that it is not appropriate. So the federal law required a decision, not an outcome. That is why the export rule at your address is set by your state legislature, your state commission and your utility's tariff, and why two neighbours across a state line can face completely different math with the same panels.
Notice also what the federal definition leaves open: it says the customer's energy may offset the utility's "during the applicable billing period" and says nothing about what happens to a surplus at the end of that period, or about which charges the offset applies to. Those two gaps, the netting period and the credited charges, are where the two state rules read on this page differ most, and both are worked below. If you are reading this because a salesperson said net metering is guaranteed by federal law, the quote red flags guide covers how to check that kind of claim.
Why this changed
The argument is about who pays for the grid. In California's proceeding that replaced its net metering tariff, the commission's Decision 22-12-056 records the Joint Utilities arguing that the cost shift from participating to non-participating customers is the result of non-participating customers overcompensating net energy metering customers for exports, and records the California Solar and Storage Association contending that the commission's Avoided Cost Calculator undervalues exports and would result in reduced compensation and significantly lengthier payback periods.
For your roof, the philosophy matters less than the current rule and its next scheduled review. Build your math on the rule that exists, and stress-test it against the rule that might replace it.
Illinois: partial credit, written into the statute
Illinois shows how much detail hides inside the words net metering. Its rule is in the Public Utilities Act at 220 ILCS 5/16-107.5. Customers who registered for net metering before January 1, 2025 keep the older service for the lifetime of the system. Under subsection (d) of that older service, a monthly surplus earns a 1:1 kilowatt-hour credit carried to later bills, and remaining credits expire at the end of the year or annualized period. The statute says the legacy service continues regardless of whether those customers change electricity providers or the customer benefiting from the system changes. The statute makes the electric utility serving more than 200,000 customers as of January 1, 2021 responsible for ensuring those billing credits continue without lapse.
For customers who begin net metering after that date, subsection (n) applies. If the customer produces more than it uses in a monthly billing period, the provider applies a one-for-one kilowatt-hour energy or monetary credit for kilowatt-hour supply charges to the next bill, and the customer chooses between kilowatt-hour and monetary credit when applying. The statute defines kilowatt-hour supply charges as the kilowatt-hour equivalent values for energy, capacity, transmission, and the purchased energy adjustment, if applicable, and requires the provider to carry excess credits over to later billing periods; unlike the older rule, the subsection (n) text read for this guide does not say those credits expire. Paragraph (3) then states the other half: the customer remains responsible for the gross amount of delivery services charges, supply-related charges that are kilowatt based, and all taxes and fees related to such charges.
Two details change the arithmetic. First, the statute's supply value includes capacity and transmission as well as energy, so a credit computed from the energy line of a bill alone would understate it; the credit covers the supply items the statute lists and stops there. Second, customers whose supply is priced hourly or by time of use are netted by the hour, not the month: for each hour the home produces more than it uses, the provider calculates a credit at that hour's energy price plus values for capacity and transmission. The partial-credit bar in the chart above is the monthly version of this rule with an illustrative supply portion. To use it for an Illinois quote, find the supply and delivery lines on a recent bill and apply the statute's split to them, rather than the all-in rate a proposal may use.
Illinois also runs rebates and a renewable energy credit market alongside the credit rule, and those are separate programs with their own terms; the solar certificate guide covers the certificate side, and the battery incentives guide reads the storage programs. Neither belongs in the export arithmetic itself.
California: net billing by commission decision
California reached its rule by a different route: a commission decision rather than a statute that writes the credit itself. A state law, Public Utilities Code Section 2827.1, directed the commission to adopt a successor tariff, and the commission set its terms. The California Public Utilities Commission adopted the Net Billing Tariff in Decision 22-12-056, and its proceeding page says the decision did not affect customers who submitted a net metering interconnection application by April 14, 2023, while the successor tariff applies to customers who submit an application on or after April 15, 2023. Exports are credited at values from the commission's Avoided Cost Calculator, which vary by hour, instead of at the retail rate. The decision itself says the combination of retail import rates and those variable export values sends strong price signals to shift energy use and promotes installing storage with solar.
This is the net billing bar in the chart above, with one difference that matters: the export value is not one number but a schedule that changes by hour, month and day type, so the same 450 exported kilowatt-hours can be worth more in a summer evening than at a spring noon. The California Net Billing Tariff guide works that schedule hour by hour, and the battery guide shows why a battery has its clearest job under this kind of rule.
Retail credit assumed where it no longer applies
A payback quote built on one-for-one retail credit in a net billing territory. Ask every installer one question: what exactly do I get paid for exported energy, and where is that written?
Monthly netting, annual netting, and when credits disappear
The second gap in the federal definition is the netting period. A household's solar surplus is seasonal: it builds in long summer days and runs down in winter. Whether summer credits can pay winter bills depends on how long credits last. Here is a labelled illustration with the same 30-cent retail rate and full one-for-one credit: six summer months each with a 300 kWh surplus, and six winter months each with a 250 kWh shortfall.
Under annual netting, the 1,800 kWh of summer credits roll forward and cover the 1,500 kWh of winter shortfall. Winter energy charges are zero and 300 kWh of credit is left at the settlement date. Under monthly netting where unused credits expire, each summer month's surplus vanishes at the end of that month, worth $90 of retail energy each time, $540 across the summer, and the household still pays for 1,500 kWh in winter, $450. Same panels, same year, same rate: $450 of winter charges against none, from the length of the netting period alone.
What happens to the 300 kWh left over under annual netting is the next question, and it is set by the tariff, not the installer. The SEIA net metering overview notes that depending on state policy and utility rules, unused credits may roll over to future billing periods, be paid out after a defined time period, or expire. Where they are paid out, check the payout rate in your tariff before sizing above your usage: if it is below retail, a system sized to produce a large annual surplus earns less for that surplus than for the energy it offsets. The true-up bill guide works through how an annual settlement is calculated and how much to set aside for it. Utah's Rocky Mountain Power carries dollar export credits forward through the year and lets any balance lapse at the March meter reading, as the Utah export credit guide shows with a month-by-month bill. Iowa's statute uses the term net billing differently: there it nets kilowatt-hours over a monthly interval with a year-end cash-out, while its inflow-outflow billing pays exports at the retail volumetric rate until a value-of-solar rate is approved, as the Iowa solar billing guide sets out from the Code text.
The charges no export credit touches
Every structure above has a floor under it. Customer charges, meter charges and minimum bills are billed whether the roof exports or not, and the Illinois statute is explicit that taxes and fees and delivery charges remain payable. A labelled $12 monthly customer charge is $144 a year that no system size can remove. That matters in two ways. It lowers the realistic best case for a solar bill above zero, and it means that adding panels to chase a lower bill eventually buys nothing: once the energy charges are covered, the extra exports earn only whatever your rule pays for surplus. Read the fixed lines on a current bill before you let anyone promise you a zero bill.
To find your floor, take a recent bill and cross out every line priced per kilowatt-hour. What remains, the flat monthly charges and any charge per kilowatt of demand, is roughly what you will still pay in a month when the roof covers all your energy. Then read the tariff for anything that applies only to solar customers, such as a minimum bill, and add it. That total, times twelve, is the part of your bill no export rule and no system size can reach.
Turning the rule into a payback input
A payback estimate needs one number from all of this: the value of a year of production under your rule. It has two parts, and only one of them depends on the export rule. Energy your home uses as it is produced avoids a retail purchase under every structure. Energy exported earns whatever the rule pays. So the split between the two, the self-consumed share, decides how much the rule matters to you.
A labelled illustration makes the size of the effect plain. Take a system producing 10,000 kWh a year, with 6,000 used on site and 4,000 exported, and the same 30-cent retail rate. The 6,000 self-consumed kilowatt-hours are worth $1,800 under every rule. The 4,000 exports are worth $1,200 under full net metering, $480 under a 12-cent partial credit, and $160 under a 4-cent net billing rate. The year's total value is $3,000, $2,280 or $1,960. Because simple payback is price divided by annual value, the same system price takes about 1.32 times as long to pay back under the partial credit as under full net metering, and about 1.53 times as long under net billing.
Now move the self-consumed share and watch the gap change. If the same household exported only 2,000 kWh, the net billing year would be worth $2,480 against $3,000; if it exported 6,000 kWh, only $1,440 against $3,000. Under full net metering the split does not matter at all. Under net billing it is the biggest lever you have, which is why shifting laundry, dishwashing or car charging into midday hours, or adding storage, changes payback under one rule and does nothing under another. Ask any proposal for its assumed export share, and check the payback against the rule you actually have. Where the export rate pays very little, a system built never to export is also allowed in some places, and the non-export solar rules and self-use test show when giving up the credit costs less than the tariff.
How to use your export rule before you size anything
Find the rule before you fall for a system size. (Plug-in devices are a separate case: the ten state plug-in solar laws read on that page mostly exclude them from net metering or leave their exports uncompensated.) Any quote that names a payback without naming your export rule is quoting a tariff it has not read. The 2026 break-even tables show how far a lower export credit raises the value per kWh a system must earn.
Read your utility tariff for four things: the export price or credit structure, whether credits roll over or expire, any minimum bill or fixed charge that survives your production, and the date of the next scheduled review. Expiring credits reward sizing close to usage. Rollover rewards patience. A minimum bill sets a floor under your savings no panel count can remove. Save the current residential solar page or tariff sheet with your quote documents, because that document, not a neighbor's memory of an older program, prices your exports.
Then size and store against the rule you found. Retail credit can support sizing near annual usage. Net billing pushes value toward daytime self-consumption and gives storage a real job, as California's Net Billing Tariff, worked hour by hour, shows. A buyback contract should be read like a tariff in its own right, because the feed-in price is half the product. Stress-test the payback once more against the rule that might replace yours; export structures have changed in California and Illinois within the last few years, and a system that only works under the most generous reading is a fragile purchase. Some states pay twice, once for exports and once for the output itself, as the solar certificate guide shows market by market.
3,000 exported kWh at retail and at export rates
A system exports 3,000 kWh a year. At a 30-cent retail rate with one-for-one credit, that energy is worth $900. At a 4-cent export rate, it is worth $120. The panels, roof, and sunshine are identical; the policy moved the value by $780 a year and the payback by years. Anyone quoting payback without naming your export rule is quoting fiction.
How to read the export lines on your own bill
Once the system is running, the export rule stops being a policy page and becomes four lines on your bill. A bidirectional meter tracks both directions of flow: electricity delivered from the grid to your home and electricity received by the grid from your roof. The bill then applies your structure to those two flows. Under kilowatt-hour netting, exports offset imports before pricing. Under net billing, the two flows are priced separately, imports at the retail rate and exports at the export rate, and the statement shows a credit line instead of a smaller usage line. The Solar Energy Industries Association net metering overview, checked October 29, 2026, describes the same mechanics and the same caution: unused credits may roll over to a later billing period, be paid out after a defined period, or expire, and which of those happens is set by state policy and your utility's rules, not by your installer.
Read a labelled illustration with the same rates the example on this page already uses, a 30-cent retail rate and a 4-cent export rate. In a month when the home imports 700 kWh and exports 450 kWh, kilowatt-hour netting bills the difference: 250 kWh at 30 cents is $75 of energy charges before fixed charges. Net billing prices both flows: 700 kWh at 30 cents is $210, minus 450 kWh at 4 cents, an $18 credit, for $192 of energy charges before fixed charges. Same roof, same month, same sunshine. The $117 gap is the export rule, printed on your own statement where you can audit it.
So audit it, on the first two or three bills. Find the delivered and received lines and check they are both present; a bill that only shows net usage under a net billing tariff is missing the line that prices your exports. Find the credit balance carried forward and the true-up or expiration date attached to it, and compare both against the tariff sheet you saved before signing. Find the fixed charges that survive production, including any minimum bill, because they set the floor your energy credits cannot offset. If a line does not match the rule you saved, ask the utility which document controls before you ask the installer to re-run the payback math.
Find your own export rule
- Find your utility's current residential solar or net metering page and save it.
- Ask whether excess is credited at retail, avoided cost, or a fixed export rate, and whether credits expire.
- Check for minimum bills or fixed charges that apply no matter how much you produce.
- Model your payback with the export rule first, the sunshine second.
- On your first bills, check the delivered, received, and credit-carryforward lines against the tariff rule you saved, and find the true-up or expiration date for your credits.
- If your state credits only part of the bill, find which charge lines the credit covers on a recent bill, and price exports at that portion, not the all-in rate.
Export credit questions
What is the difference between net metering and net billing?
Net metering credits exports at or near the retail rate, with rollover rules set by the tariff. Net billing pays a lower export price, time-varying in California, while charging full retail for imports. The hardware is the same; the value of surplus energy is not.
Do my credits expire?
Sometimes, depending on the utility and state. Some structures let credits roll within a year and true-up annually, others settle monthly. Expiring credits reward sizing to usage; rollover rewards patience. Your tariff sheet says which.
Where do I find my actual export rate?
On your utility current residential solar or net metering page and in its tariff sheet, and in DSIRE entries for your state and utility. Ask every installer to name the export value in their payback math and show where it is written. Program names and values change through legislation and rate cases, so the tariff in force when you sign is the only authoritative version.
What is a buyback plan, and how is it different?
A buyback plan is a retail contract with a named feed-in price for exported energy, offered by some retail electricity suppliers. It can differ from both retail net metering and utility net billing, and plans vary by provider while some offer none. Read the plan like a tariff: the export price, its term, and its escalator decide what your surplus is worth.
Why does my bill show separate delivered and received numbers?
Because the meter tracks both directions of flow. Delivered is the electricity your home took from the grid; received is the electricity your system sent to it. Under kilowatt-hour netting the two are offset before pricing. Under net billing each is priced at its own rate, so both lines and the credit line between them are the audit trail for what your exports actually earned. If your tariff is net billing and the bill shows only one net figure, ask the utility for the import and export lines behind it.
Does federal law require net metering?
Not as an outcome. The Energy Policy Act of 2005 added a net metering standard to the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act (16 U.S.C. 2621(d)(11)), but subsection (a) required each state regulatory authority to consider the standard and decide whether implementing it is appropriate, and allowed a state to decide it is not. The rule at your address comes from your state and your utility tariff.
What changed in Illinois net metering in 2025?
Under 220 ILCS 5/16-107.5, customers who registered before January 1, 2025 keep the older net metering service for the lifetime of the system. Customers who start afterward get credits for kilowatt-hour supply charges, which the statute defines as energy, capacity, transmission and the purchased energy adjustment, while remaining responsible for the gross amount of delivery charges, taxes and fees. Excess credits carry over.
Sources and verification
- DSIRE, Database of State Incentives for Renewables and Efficiency: Net metering and distributed generation policy entries by state and utility. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA), Net Metering: Exports measured through a bidirectional meter; depending on state policy and utility rules, unused credits may roll over to future billing periods, be paid out after a defined time period, or expire. Checked October 29, 2026.
- 16 U.S.C. 2621, Consideration and determination respecting certain ratemaking standards (PURPA section 111), via Cornell LII: Subsection (d)(11) net metering standard, added by Pub. L. 109-58 (Energy Policy Act of 2005), section 1251(a); subsection (a) requires each state regulatory authority to consider each standard and determine whether it is appropriate to implement it, and does not prohibit a determination that it is not. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Illinois Public Utilities Act, 220 ILCS 5/16-107.5 (net electricity metering): Pre-2025 registrants keep net metering for the lifetime of the system; subsection (n) for later customers: 1:1 kWh or monetary credit for kilowatt-hour supply charges (energy, capacity, transmission, purchased energy adjustment), choice made at application, excess credits carried over, hourly netting for hourly or time-of-use supply; paragraph (3): customer remains responsible for gross delivery services charges, kW-based supply charges, and taxes and fees. Checked October 29, 2026.
- California Public Utilities Commission, Decision 22-12-056 (December 15, 2022): Net Billing Tariff with export compensation from the Avoided Cost Calculator; record of the Joint Utilities' cost-shift position and CALSSA's contention that the calculator undervalues exports. Checked October 29, 2026.
- California Public Utilities Commission, NEM Revisit proceeding page: The decision did not affect customers who submitted a NEM interconnection application by April 14, 2023; the successor tariff applies to applications on or after April 15, 2023. Checked October 29, 2026.
Export rules are set by state legislatures, state regulators and individual utilities, and change through laws and rate cases. The Illinois and California rules on this page were read from the statute and the commission decision on October 29, 2026; the rates in the worked examples are labelled illustrations, not any utility's prices. Your utility's current tariff is the only authoritative version for your address; this page explains how to read it.